In 1999, Park Chan-wook named movies by Kubrick, Hitchcock, Malick, and extra as among the most overrated ever.
We love seeing which movies rank amongst our favourite administrators’ checklist of greatest ever — those that left a mark and steered them within the path of changing into among the most famous artists of the medium. However let’s face it, we don’t thoughts somewhat battle, both. However Park Chan-wook wasn’t going after his fellow administrators in a bodily approach however somewhat in a way more damming approach — attacking their work!
In a lately unearthed slam session from 1999, Park Chan-wook referred to as out 10 movies that he thought of probably the most overrated ever. Needless to say by this level, the South Korean director solely had two options to his credit score. So what’s on the checklist and what did he must say? Let’s test it out:
Park Chan-wook primarily took concern with American movies, opening the checklist with Oliver Stone’s Pure Born Killers, which might hardly be referred to as overrated contemplating it has all the time been insanely divisive. Regardless, he mentioned of the 1994 movie, “This movie steals from the works of true impartial cinema and makes an enormous fuss promoting all of them out.” Heading later into the Nineteen Nineties, Park Chan-wook referred to as out Terrence Malick’s The Skinny Purple Line (#7) for being completely undefined and having “pedantic monologues.” He, too, didn’t suppose that Alex Proyas’ Darkish Metropolis (#8) deserved any of the reward younger filmmakers had been giving it. And he took it even additional with David Lynch’s Misplaced Freeway (#3), calling it “pretentious” aka just about the worst factor you possibly can name a movie.
Park Chan-wook additionally slighted Alfred Hitchcock’s Psycho (exterior of the bathe scene and Bernard Herrmann rating) and Stanley Kubrick’s Full Metallic Jacket, which got here in at #1. On that, he mentioned, “Kubrick is one thing of a mysticized determine. This movie specifically could be very inferior to his different works. The recruits coaching of the primary half is superior, however the latter half in Vietnam is a dud.” And sure, he did make room for the granddaddy of all, Citizen Kane (#9), saying it was “a self-indulgent show of methods with none emotional resonance to justify its scale.” He would go on to reward Orson Welles’ later works, presumably which means his contributions to the frozen peas business.
For extra worldwide fare, Park Chan-wook put Japan’s Hana-bi at #2, Hong Kong’s Chungking Categorical at #5 and The Massive Blue at #6.
All of us have our checklist of most overrated movies ever so it’s cool to see what Park Chan-wook places on his personal checklist. Personally, I can see justification for one thing like Psycho and Full Metallic Jacket despite the fact that I’m an enormous fan of each. Nonetheless, his gripe with Citizen Kane is a bit novice and apparent, whereas I’ll by no means tolerate any type of The Skinny Purple Line bashing. However go on, Park, you inform Oliver Stone’s what’s up!
What do you make of Park Chan-wook’s checklist of probably the most overrated movies ever? Do you suppose he has robust takes or is he off base? Give us your take under!
