Beth Anne Pike has been promoting actual property in Riverhead, N.Y., for 20 years and can’t fairly clarify the city’s sudden recognition.
“Is it as a result of farther east the costs have gotten uncontrolled?” she requested about an exploding housing market that has made the North Fork of Lengthy Island unaffordable for a lot of of its longtime residents. “Or has it simply grow to be extra fascinating due to its location?”
Marking the tip of the Lengthy Island Expressway’s 71-mile stretch of banality, Riverhead is thought for its farms, seashores, orchards, paddocks, golf programs, big-box shops, water park, raceway and vineyards. To many individuals, the city, which includes the 15-square-mile census-designated place referred to as Riverhead and several other surrounding hamlets, is a signpost moderately than a vacation spot. Rolling off the freeway right into a shock of East Finish greenery, vacationers begin to rely down the minutes to pastoral North Fork communities like Mattituck, Southold and Orient.
Recently, nevertheless, an inflow of residents and guests has jammed the roads east, and people minutes have piled up. What was once a fluid half-hour drive from Riverhead to Greenport, 22 miles away, can now take greater than an hour, relying on the month. (Autumn harvest season, which attracts pumpkin pickers, is the worst, locals say.) If the city as soon as repelled some rural-home seekers with its gritty pockets and suburbanized spots, like Tanger Shops, a shopping center on West Most important Avenue, it now shines with the benefit of proximity to the Hamptons, Nassau County and Manhattan. It’s straightforward to get to, straightforward to go away.
On the similar time, Riverhead is intent on giving folks a cause to hold round. For a few a long time, the city has been including or repairing cultural touchstones on or close to its historic Most important Avenue, together with the Lengthy Island Aquarium; the 1881 Vail-Leavitt Music Corridor; Tweed’s Restaurant and Buffalo Bar, within the Victorian-era John J. Sullivan Resort constructing; and the Artwork Deco-style Suffolk Theater, which is present process enlargement. Becoming a member of them will likely be a relocated Lengthy Island Science Middle with a rooftop planetarium.
Because the pandemic has receded, new companies have taken root or grown. Latest arrivals on Most important Avenue embody the Peconic County Brewing, the Privet consignment warehouse promoting residence items from Hamptons property gross sales, the Cuban restaurant Lucha Cubano, and the restaurant and catering firm Insatiable Eats Artistic Kitchen. This month, the East Finish Meals Market, a winter farmers’ market on Most important Street, northeast of downtown, introduced plans to stay open year-round.
Rezoning for mixed-use improvement will proceed to “convey life to the downtown that left when it not was our central enterprise district,” mentioned Daybreak Thomas, the city’s group improvement director.
A venture referred to as City Sq., spurred by an $800,000 state grant and shortly to profit from a further $10 million in state funding, will open Most important Avenue to the Peconic River and create retail and out of doors occasion areas. (The world, which was inundated by Hurricane Sandy in 2012, is being developed with an eye fixed to flood prevention, Ms. Thomas mentioned.)
About 300 housing items, in a mixture of reasonably priced and market-rate, have been added or are within the means of being constructed downtown, and 200 market-rate items are on the boards. When Riverview Lofts, for instance, was accomplished in 2020 on East Most important Avenue, the 105 residences (excluding 18 put aside for residents with bodily disabilities) ranged from $1,095 for a below-market-rate studio to $2,500 for a market-rate two-bedroom. (No items are presently accessible.) One other 240 market-rate items are being deliberate for a transit-oriented district within the blighted space close to the practice station.
Expressing confidence that the prevailing infrastructure can assist progress, Ms. Thomas mentioned these new developments will assist present reduction to the realm’s employees, who’ve been priced out of the housing market.
Nevertheless it’s not simply laborers on this agricultural group who’re fighting affordability, she mentioned. “The housing hole is within the single-family dwelling space. You may get an condominium, however not a home.” Her purpose, she mentioned, is “to assist fill in these blanks.”
What You’ll Discover
The county seat of Suffolk County, Riverhead stretches over 201 sq. miles of land and water, and accommodates all or a part of the unincorporated hamlets of Baiting Hole, Northville, Laurel, Jamesport, Aquebogue, Calverton, Manorville and Wading River.
The city has 4 public seashores — three on Lengthy Island Sound — and several other nature preserves, together with a bathroom the place cranberries had been as soon as harvested. Indian Island County Park, a 275-acre leisure spot on the mouth of the Peconic River, attracts hikers, campers, bird-watchers and fishers. Persevering with a apply begun in the course of the pandemic, the city is proscribing parking at its seashores to residents. An annual allow is $20.
Riverhead is standard with retirees, who can select amongst a number of communities for folks 55 years and older. Final yr, the Peconic Bay Medical Middle, which is a part of the Northwell Well being system, unveiled a $67.8 million critical-care pavilion that doubled the scale of the earlier trauma facility.
In 2016, Susan and Robert Lorenz spent $440,000 for a 2,100-square-foot, two-story rental at Stoneleigh Woods, a 55-plus improvement two miles northwest of downtown and fewer than a mile from the medical heart. The couple, who even have a house in Naples, Fla., paid a premium for a unit that backs onto a golf course, mentioned Ms. Lorenz, 69, a retired vice chairman of gross sales at a home-furnishings firm.
The rental’s annual property taxes of $4,500 are lower than a 3rd of what the Lorenzes paid in Huntington, N.Y., the place they lived beforehand. However that’s additionally low cost for Riverhead, which regardless of sturdy business exercise has the very best taxes on the North Fork. The couple has been spared, Ms. Lorenz believes, as a result of a big proportion of property taxes goes to funding the college system, and Stoneleigh Woods doesn’t allow residents beneath the age of 19. “It’s actually for retirees,” she mentioned.
Katherine Liepe-Levinson, 68, and her husband, Martin Levinson, 76, additionally got here to Riverhead as part-timers. After dwelling in an 1,100-square-foot manufactured residence in a 55-plus enclave close to the Lengthy Island State Pine Barrens Protect, they upsized in 2018 to a four-bedroom home on the Highlands Membership, a householders’ affiliation set on dozens of acres. Throughout the pandemic they bought their main residence, in Forest Hills, Queens.
“If I stand right here, I can see Briermere Farms,” mentioned Ms. Liepe-Levinson, referring to a enterprise on Sound Avenue that’s celebrated for its fruit pies.
The 2009 home on virtually half an acre on the Highlands Membership had issues, however when Ms. Liepe-Levinson, a photographer, regarded out the kitchen window and noticed a barn, “That was it,” she mentioned. The couple paid $520,000 and spent extra on repairs. The property taxes are about $13,000.
Just a few miles north, within the Reeves Park neighborhood in Baiting Hole, a beachfront group on Lengthy Island Sound, Jennifer Sigelakis Agneta has been dwelling full-time since 2017 in a 545-square-foot cottage purchased initially for weekends. In 2015, the cottage price $195,000. “Now, I don’t suppose you would purchase into this neighborhood for lower than $400,000,” she mentioned.
Ms. Sigelakis Agneta, who’s 57 and works in actual property advertising and marketing, mentioned she respects why many longtime residents miss the North Fork’s sleepy methods. However having lived in downtown Salisbury, Md., she mentioned she is aware of what a financially depressed group with low property values seems to be like. She is ready to cheer on the pumpkin pickers.
“Yeah, there’s extra visitors and individuals who don’t know the way to drive in visitors circles,” she mentioned. However the inflow “additionally helps us to get extra issues within the space. Perhaps we’ll get a movie show someday.”
What You’ll Pay
In mid-March, a Zillow search confirmed 43 properties within the hamlet of Riverhead listed by brokers. Amongst them had been a number of manufactured homes in communities for households or folks 55 years and older; asking costs started at $50,000 (for the construction alone), with a month-to-month lot rental price of $723 that included taxes. Transferring up in worth, a four-bedroom, wood-shingled home in-built 1930 close to Most important Avenue was listed for $599,990, with annual taxes of $7,849. Six years in the past, the identical property bought for $250,000.
One other four-bedroom, wood-sided home in-built 1930, with Lengthy Island Sound views and deeded seaside entry, was listed for just below $1.4 million, with annual taxes of $16,385. In 2008, the home bought for $430,000.
In line with Redfin, the median sale worth within the hamlet of Riverhead in February was $550,000, based mostly on seven transactions, a year-over-year improve of fifty p.c.
Riverhead, on the crux of the bifurcated East Finish, factors to extra than simply geographical range. The city’s inhabitants of almost 36,000 identifies itself as 15.3 p.c Hispanic, 9.9 p.c Black, 2 p.c Asian and 1 p.c multiracial, in accordance with 2020 census knowledge. Farmhouses, suburban ranch homes and Twenty first-century colonials sprouting from fields combine with seaside cottages, gaudy Victorians and enormous, boxy constructions trying homesick for an workplace park.
“I by no means thought I might be speaking about tractors and, on the similar time, go meals purchasing at Cease & Store,” mentioned Stephanie Pincar-Coleman, 37, who’s initially from Staten Island and lives together with her husband and two younger youngsters in Aquebogue. “And if we’d like eggs, we stroll all the way down to the farm.”
On Center Street, which connects to Most important Avenue in Riverhead, “you’ll be able to actually cross a buffalo farm and sod farms,” she mentioned. “You may see cows on the facet of the street.”
The Riverhead Central College District, which serves about 5,400 college students from Riverhead, Southampton and Brookhaven townships, includes 4 kindergarten-to-fourth-grade elementary colleges, one fifth-to-sixth-grade elementary faculty, one seventh-to-eighth-grade center faculty and one highschool.
Riverhead Excessive College enrolls about 1,900 college students; 53 p.c outline themselves as Hispanic or Latino, 35 p.c as white, 10 p.c as Black, 1 p.c as Asian or Pacific Islander and 1 p.c as multiracial. The 2021 commencement fee was 82 p.c. 1 / 4 of the senior class handed at the very least one Superior Placement check final yr.
A $32.5 million program to increase and renovate the highschool constructing and enhance the campus it shares with Riverhead Center College and Phillips Avenue Elementary College was accomplished in 2015.
Riverhead is 90 minutes by automotive from Manhattan (in gentle visitors). Lengthy Island Rail Street gives service to Pennsylvania Station two or 3 times a day. A weekday practice departing at 6:03 a.m., with transfers in Ronkonkoma, N.Y., and Jamaica in Queens, arrives in Manhattan at 7:59 a.m. The fare is $30.50 peak and $22.25 off-peak, or $450 a month.
Buses on Hampton Jitney’s North Fork line depart Riverhead for varied factors in Manhattan Monday by means of Friday at 5:15 a.m., and every day at 8:40 a.m., with extra service all through the day and on weekends. The journey is about two hours, and the fare is $29 pay as you go or $36 on board; a ebook of 12 tickets is $289.
The Historical past
Named for its place on the Peconic River, which was as soon as occupied partially by the Corchaug folks, Riverhead was carved out of the city of Southold in 1792 to make administration extra manageable. (The territory was thought of too massive for residents to comfortably attend city conferences.)
The 15-block Polish City enclave within the hamlet of Riverhead was settled by Polish immigrants fleeing the chaos of Japanese Europe within the early twentieth century. Their affect is notable in avenue names like Pulaski and in an annual competition begun in 1974 that options conventional meals, costumes, crafts and polka music.
For weekly e mail updates on residential actual property information, enroll right here. Observe us on Twitter: @nytrealestate.