The Revenue Tax Act of 1961 has undergone innumerable amendments since its inception (4,000, as said by the finance minister in Parliament). Traditionally, successive governments have used tax as an instrument to incentivize particular industries, promote investments in sure areas, or to encourage international change earnings. Because of this, quite a few provisions have been added through the years to supply sectoral, regional or particular activity-related advantages. Moreover, numerous explanations, provisos and exceptions have been launched to make clear or nullify the impression of judicial pronouncements.
Over time, this made the Act unwieldy, more and more complicated and troublesome to navigate, even for practising accountants and attorneys. Decoding the legislation at this time requires sifting by means of an amazing variety of sections, schedules and amendments earlier than arriving at a transparent understanding. Whereas the Act has 298 sections, it has a number of alpha-numerical sections too, taking the entire to greater than 800. In brief, it’s mind-boggling.
Additionally Learn: Simplify India’s GST regime: The case for it’s clear and it’s time to behave
Recognizing this complexity, the federal government in recent times has sought to simplify the tax construction whereas decreasing tax charges. The introduction of a brand new company tax regime, providing corporations the choice of a decrease 25% tax fee (plus surcharge) with out making deduction claims or a 30% fee (plus surcharge) with the flexibility to assert deductions, was a serious step on this path.
Since deduction claims usually led to extended litigation, a major variety of companies have regularly migrated to the no-deduction lower-rate regime.
The federal government prolonged this strategy past corporates by encouraging particular person income-tax payers to change over to a brand new and simplified tax regime. With the Finance Act of 2024, a major shift in direction of the brand new regime is anticipated among the many nation’s particular person taxpayers.
This brings us to a elementary challenge. We’ve got an outdated Revenue Tax Act, burdened with out of date provisions and a cumbersome construction, particularly within the context of financial liberalization, which lowered the federal government’s position within the economic system. Provided that the Centre has undertaken main reforms in recent times—introducing a brand new Corporations Act, overhauling civil and felony legal guidelines and implementing GST—it was solely logical to take the following step: Rewriting the Revenue Tax Act of 1961.
Additionally Learn: Revise direct taxes: Company taxation must be progressive
The Revenue Tax Invoice of 2025, introduced in Parliament on Thursday, marks a major second. The draft legislation is structurally extra coherent and eliminates redundant provisions which have outlived their relevance. Not like the present Act, whose provisions are scattered throughout a number of sections, the brand new invoice follows a logical and streamlined construction, making it simpler to interpret.
Starting with the elimination of over-wrought definitions for ‘earlier 12 months’ and ‘evaluation 12 months’ and referring as a substitute to ‘tax 12 months,’ the Invoice’s language is clearer, concise and fewer vulnerable to a number of interpretations, thereby lowering the potential for litigation.
The alpha-numerical provisions have been changed with sections and the Invoice now has 536 of them, in contrast with greater than 800. There are clear tables and charts (over 50), which is able to make it simple to observe the provisions. Many of those, like these pertaining to tax deducted at supply (TDS) and non-profit organizations, are positioned collectively in a coherent method.
That stated, the Invoice doesn’t search to introduce substantive adjustments. Certainly, the fundamental character of the Act stays intact. Its broad heads of revenue, computation methodologies, set-off and carry-forward provisions for losses, the TDS mechanism, the appeals framework and the penalty and prosecution guidelines stay largely unchanged.
Nevertheless, by simplifying the general authorized framework for taxation and bettering readability, the Invoice creates a powerful basis for deeper structural reforms sooner or later.
Additionally Learn: India’s taxation disaster: Can 1% bear such a big nation’s burden?
The Invoice has been referred to a Choose Committee of Parliament, which has to revert with feedback earlier than the second a part of the finances session. Thus, the Invoice is anticipated to be enacted quickly sufficient to pave the best way for its implementation on the earliest.
The federal government has been soliciting suggestions from trade chambers, skilled our bodies and different stakeholders on the reforms India’s tax system wants. Hundreds of suggestions have been submitted.
These broadly concentrate on: a) Minimizing tax litigation, making certain sooner dispute decision by setting clear timelines for it and offering for settlements reached with out litigation; b) Simplifying the compliance burden of taxpayers by streamlining provisions akin to for TDS to make them extra sensible and fewer litigation susceptible; c) Facilitating company restructuring by making enterprise mergers, de-mergers and re-organizations extra seamless and tax-efficient; d) Rationalizing penalties and decriminalizing tax offences by making certain that penal measures are proportionate to violations and ridding the legislation of felony provisions the place they’re pointless.
Little question, these discussions are underway within the finance ministry. Over time, we will hope to see amendments aimed toward addressing these considerations and additional bettering the nation’s tax framework. For now, the Revenue Tax Invoice 2025 units the stage for a contemporary and secure tax regime by means of a legislation that’s simpler to know, reader-friendly and properly positioned for future reforms.
The writer is CEO, Dhruva Advisors.
