Index Investing News
Sunday, May 25, 2025
No Result
View All Result
  • Login
  • Home
  • World
  • Investing
  • Financial
  • Economy
  • Markets
  • Stocks
  • Crypto
  • Property
  • Sport
  • Entertainment
  • Opinion
  • Home
  • World
  • Investing
  • Financial
  • Economy
  • Markets
  • Stocks
  • Crypto
  • Property
  • Sport
  • Entertainment
  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
Index Investing News
No Result
View All Result

Freedom and the Limits of Intellectuals

by Index Investing News
June 9, 2023
in Economy
Reading Time: 4 mins read
A A
0
Home Economy
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


Edmund Burke once said, “It is the nature of all greatness not to be exact.” There is a certain kind of conversation I often have that brings this point to mind. I often argue that we underestimate the degree to which bottom-up, evolved orders can solve the kinds of public goods or externality problems that some insist can only be solved through top-down coercion. Occasionally, an interlocuter will follow up with what they imagine is a killer question—“Do you have a specific mechanism in mind people will use to solve this particular problem?” But asking this question only shows one has misunderstood the argument.

Innovation occurs when someone comes up with an idea that nobody has thought of before. By their very nature, innovative ideas can’t be identified in advance. If we already knew what they were, they wouldn’t be innovative ideas, they would be established ideas. Similarly, freedom isn’t simply the liberty to stick to established ideas—freedom means giving people the room to deal with the troubles of life in ways that are new and innovative, ways that haven’t been tried before or specified in advance. In advance, I could not have identified the specific mechanisms people would have used to solve common pool resource problems of the kind Elinor Ostrom made a career out of identifying. Nor could I, in advance, have specified the “custom of the orchard” that emerged among beekeepers to handle the externalities associated with beekeeping. I’ve criticized this sort of thinking with the terribly clunky term “the 5-1 error” before—the inability to see solutions to collective action problems that evolve organically because one can only conceive of them as functioning by known mechanisms specified in advance.

There is a certain breed of intellectual who holds their intellect in such high esteem that they fail to grasp how little their own mind can contain about the world around them. Thus, if they cannot see or identify a way for people to solve a problem among themselves, that’s as good as saying no such solution exists. Alternatively, intellectuals of this sort can go a step further, and offer a positive argument for why bottom-up solutions cannot work, thus requiring top-down coercive solutions to be created and imposed by…well, intellectuals such as themselves.

In terms of raw brainpower, few people in history could claim to be at the level of John Stuart Mill. Yet Mill had many curious blind spots. He was very concerned with issues of distribution over production, because he believed the potential for productive growth had basically peaked—so all further improvements in the standard of living would have to come about through ever more efficient and clever distribution instead of increased production. He worried that we would soon run out of music to create, because the range of musical notes we can hear is finite and the number of possible note combinations is also finite. From his armchair, he produced an argument for why lighthouses, as public goods, could not be provided on the private market and thus required public provision.

But Mill was wrong about all of these things. It should be obvious to the reader how Mill failed to predict how our capacity for production would continue to grow, and that musical innovation has only grown as well. But these are only failures of prediction on Mill’s part. His conclusion about lighthouses was not merely a failure of prediction, it was a failure of observation as well. Even as Mill made that argument, as Michael Munger points out, “most—more than three-quarters—of all lighthouses had been built, and were being operated, by private individuals.” Had Mill gotten out of his armchair and gone out to a port to check, he could have seen that his argument was mistaken, and people found private solutions to the public goods problem. But he saw no need to check—he had his argument showing private actors couldn’t solve the public goods problem and state action was needed. He saw no mechanism that he could specify in advance to solve this problem—which was as good as proving no such mechanism existed. J. E. Meade, too, had his argument for why beekeepers could not solve the externality problems related to beekeeping, and he felt no need to bother to actually check to see if he was right. He couldn’t think of a way to specify a solution, so no solution existed as far as he was concerned. He was wrong too.

If people were only granted freedom when its benefits can be identified and specified in advance, freedom and innovation would utterly cease. Too many intellectuals see themselves as fit to set the boundaries on other peoples’ freedoms based on nothing more than the limits of their own understanding. As is often the case, Thomas Sowell said it better than anyone else:

Freedom is not simply the right of intellectuals to circulate their merchandise. It is, above all, the right of ordinary people to find elbow room for themselves and a refuge from the rampaging presumptions of their “betters.”

 



Source link

Tags: freedomIntellectualslimits
ShareTweetShareShare
Previous Post

‘Bad dog!’ US Supreme Court rules against chew toy maker

Next Post

Teva concludes US nationwide opioid settlement

Related Posts

Donald Trump makes dangerous guess by rekindling his commerce conflict with the EU

Donald Trump makes dangerous guess by rekindling his commerce conflict with the EU

by Index Investing News
May 24, 2025
0

Donald Trump likes to make offers. And he could also be calculating that his sudden escalation of tariffs on the...

The Fed’s not making a revenue

The Fed’s not making a revenue

by Index Investing News
May 24, 2025
0

Unlock the Editor’s Digest free of chargeRoula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favorite tales on this weekly publication.The...

Trump’s subsequent 100 days

Trump’s subsequent 100 days

by Index Investing News
May 24, 2025
0

This week, Swamp Notes goes to London for a dwell recording. Katie Martin, host of the Unhedged podcast, and Chris...

Greenback notches greatest weekly drop since tariffs sell-off over US debt fears

Greenback notches greatest weekly drop since tariffs sell-off over US debt fears

by Index Investing News
May 24, 2025
0

Unlock the Editor’s Digest totally freeRoula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favorite tales on this weekly e-newsletter.Investor jitters...

Donald Trump ‘not in search of deal’ as he threatens EU with 50% tariff

Donald Trump ‘not in search of deal’ as he threatens EU with 50% tariff

by Index Investing News
May 24, 2025
0

Unlock the White Home Watch publication without spending a dimeYour information to what Trump’s second time period means for Washington,...

Next Post
Teva concludes US nationwide opioid settlement

Teva concludes US nationwide opioid settlement

Investing with AI Models: Uncovering Hidden Trading Patterns

Investing with AI Models: Uncovering Hidden Trading Patterns

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

RECOMMENDED

Expect new crypto regulations to follow Bitcoin ETFs

Expect new crypto regulations to follow Bitcoin ETFs

September 30, 2023
Browns bust Brady Quinn beefs with Deshaun Watson’s trainer

Browns bust Brady Quinn beefs with Deshaun Watson’s trainer

October 28, 2023
Two solar cycles occur at the same time, lasting 17 years each, new study reveals — Science & Technology — Sott.net

Two solar cycles occur at the same time, lasting 17 years each, new study reveals — Science & Technology — Sott.net

December 12, 2022
Chime vs Current – Which One Is Best For You?

Chime vs Current – Which One Is Best For You?

November 15, 2022
Will India be the happiest place on Earth for Disney?

Will India be the happiest place on Earth for Disney?

November 11, 2023
Pete Davidson Exhibits Off His Tattoo-Free Muscle tissues in Reformation’s Attractive Valentine’s Day Marketing campaign

Pete Davidson Exhibits Off His Tattoo-Free Muscle tissues in Reformation’s Attractive Valentine’s Day Marketing campaign

February 12, 2025
India vs England LIVE: T20 World Cup latest score and updates from semi-final as Jos Buttler and Alex Hales steering England to chase of 169

India vs England LIVE: T20 World Cup latest score and updates from semi-final as Jos Buttler and Alex Hales steering England to chase of 169

November 10, 2022
Is It Possible To Retire Now? What Supporting Your Family Looks Like in 2024

Is It Possible To Retire Now? What Supporting Your Family Looks Like in 2024

January 13, 2024
Index Investing News

Get the latest news and follow the coverage of Investing, World News, Stocks, Market Analysis, Business & Financial News, and more from the top trusted sources.

  • 1717575246.7
  • Browse the latest news about investing and more
  • Contact us
  • Cookie Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • DMCA
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • xtw18387b488

Copyright © 2022 - Index Investing News.
Index Investing News is not responsible for the content of external sites.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • World
  • Investing
  • Financial
  • Economy
  • Markets
  • Stocks
  • Crypto
  • Property
  • Sport
  • Entertainment
  • Opinion

Copyright © 2022 - Index Investing News.
Index Investing News is not responsible for the content of external sites.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In