Index Investing News
Sunday, May 25, 2025
No Result
View All Result
  • Login
  • Home
  • World
  • Investing
  • Financial
  • Economy
  • Markets
  • Stocks
  • Crypto
  • Property
  • Sport
  • Entertainment
  • Opinion
  • Home
  • World
  • Investing
  • Financial
  • Economy
  • Markets
  • Stocks
  • Crypto
  • Property
  • Sport
  • Entertainment
  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
Index Investing News
No Result
View All Result

What GDP Figures Do Not Reveal

by Index Investing News
February 2, 2024
in Economy
Reading Time: 3 mins read
A A
0
Home Economy
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


Janan Ganesh, an often original if not iconoclastic columnist, asked why bad governments such as populist ones don’t seem to undermine economic growth, at least in the short run (“Why Hasn’t Populism Done More Economic Harm,” Financial Times, January 23, 2024). This provides us with a good opportunity to review what GDP numbers cannot prove.

For seven or eight decades, it has been known to economists (at least to those who studied the issue) that, if GDP might help those who get more of it, it does not measure “social welfare” (sometimes called “aggregate utility”). There is much welfare-economics theory behind the reasons for this, but they can be intuitively rendered in a few more or less equivalent ways, or at least that’s what I will attempt to do. (The basic theory can be found in Paul A. Samuelson’s “Evaluation of Real National Income [Oxford Economic Papers, 1950] and Francis M. Bator’s “The Simple Analytics of Welfare Maximization” [American Economic Review March 1957].) Consider different descriptions of what happens after the government forces the economy to move on the production possibility frontier (PPF) by authoritatively deciding that more of something and less than something else will be produced:

  • Some consumers and possibly some workers and owners of capital are harmed. In economic jargon, the move is not a Pareto improvement. Since some gain and others lose, there is no social-scientific (economic) way to tell if “social welfare” has increased or decreased, whatever the GDP figures show. There is typically no practical way, nor even (as shown in the Samuelson article cited above) theoretical formulas, to compensate those who are harmed. Ultimately, the cause lies in the impossibility of interpersonal comparisons of utility. (Of course, if everyone gets a higher real income with nothing else changed, we would know that everyone’s utility, or individual welfare, has increased, and thus “social welfare” too.)
  • Prices, which serve to add apples and oranges to make up GDP, lose their previous correspondence with consumer valuations.
  • It is not consumer sovereignty that determines what will be produced in the economy, but government rulers or some majority. Imagine, for example, that real GDP grows at 10% and that all the growth accrues to the king, all other individuals being impoverished: “the economy” has improved, but there is no scientific way to establish that welfare has increased.
  • The free interaction between demanders and suppliers is prevented from determining what “economic growth” is made of or what it is used for. To see this in a slightly different way, imagine that as the year 2023 progressed, the state continuously seized all its subjects’ incomes over subsistence level and invested the proceeds in a portfolio mirroring the S&P 500. Given that the latter increased by 24% during the year and assuming that the government invested the money as it seized it regularly (linearly) during the year, the investment portfolio would have yielded a return of 12%. Even if the government paid this gain back to its subjects, it makes no sense to say that “the economy” grew at 12%.

To summarize: If, and to the extent that, producers are not at liberty to make money by producing what consumers demand on free markets (what is called consumer sovereignty), the configuration of the number of units of goods and services produced and their prices (GDP is the name of this configuration) is basically meaningless; or, if you will, it represents what the rulers want to be produced at prices that represent the trade-offs they make.

In economic jargon, a government-dictated increase in GDP does not signal a Pareto improvement, that is, an increase in the welfare of some individuals without a decrease in the welfare of anybody else. Most economists, however, would view as Pareto improvements the production or financing of “public goods” wanted by everybody but not excludable to non-payers (such as territorial defense), as well as the reduction of “externalities.”

Thus, if a ruler’s dirigiste policies result in the production of, say, more steel and less wheat, an increase in GDP does not imply that the economy has grown in the sense of increasing the value of consumption as evaluated by the consumers themselves. It is only in the longer run and mainly negatively that the evolution of GDP (per capita) can lead to some conclusion: if it plunges or stagnates (as it did in Argentina for long periods), we may, especially if other indicators confirm the trend, consider that as a refutation of the ruler’s beneficial contribution to economic efficiency.

*****************************************

Featured image: Busts of Juan and Evita Peron covered with snow.



Source link

Tags: figuresGDPReveal
ShareTweetShareShare
Previous Post

MiB: Tom Hancock, GMO Focused Equity

Next Post

I Want to Give My Daughter and Her Husband $50,000 For a Down Payment. Do I Have to Worry About the Gift Tax?

Related Posts

Donald Trump delays threatened 50% tariffs on EU to July 9

Donald Trump delays threatened 50% tariffs on EU to July 9

by Index Investing News
May 25, 2025
0

Unlock the White Home Watch e-newsletter at no costYour information to what Trump’s second time period means for Washington, enterprise...

Billy Joel: My Life – The Massive Image

Billy Joel: My Life – The Massive Image

by Index Investing News
May 25, 2025
0

    Bob Lefsetz: We are inclined to assume life has an on/off change. You’re both alive or your useless....

How is the Federal Reserve reacting to Donald Trump’s commerce conflict?

How is the Federal Reserve reacting to Donald Trump’s commerce conflict?

by Index Investing News
May 25, 2025
0

Unlock the White Home Watch publication at no costYour information to what Trump’s second time period means for Washington, enterprise...

SoftBank’s Masayoshi Son floats thought of US-Japan sovereign wealth fund

SoftBank’s Masayoshi Son floats thought of US-Japan sovereign wealth fund

by Index Investing News
May 25, 2025
0

Unlock the White Home Watch e-newsletter without costYour information to what Trump’s second time period means for Washington, enterprise and...

The Ethics of Inequality – Econlib

The Ethics of Inequality – Econlib

by Index Investing News
May 25, 2025
0

In an period marked by rising tensions over social justice, wealth redistribution, and the position of the state, it's sensible...

Next Post
I Want to Give My Daughter and Her Husband ,000 For a Down Payment. Do I Have to Worry About the Gift Tax?

I Want to Give My Daughter and Her Husband $50,000 For a Down Payment. Do I Have to Worry About the Gift Tax?

How a law has turned the tables on interfaith couples

How a law has turned the tables on interfaith couples

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

RECOMMENDED

Dozens Reported Killed in Iran in Blasts Near Qassim Suleimani’s Tomb

Dozens Reported Killed in Iran in Blasts Near Qassim Suleimani’s Tomb

January 3, 2024
The social isolation disaster: Making associates prices cash but it surely’s all value it

The social isolation disaster: Making associates prices cash but it surely’s all value it

December 20, 2024
Elliptic analysis reveals over 0M stolen from Atomic Wallet

Elliptic analysis reveals over $100M stolen from Atomic Wallet

June 13, 2023
SoftBank hits 4-mth high on reports of Intel joining Arm IPO By Investing.com

SoftBank hits 4-mth high on reports of Intel joining Arm IPO By Investing.com

June 13, 2023
Russian Army Turning Out the Lights: US Losing Electricity War in Ukraine

Russian Army Turning Out the Lights: US Losing Electricity War in Ukraine

October 10, 2022
Molson Coors Beverage Firm (TAP) Q1 2022 Earnings Name Transcript

Molson Coors Beverage Firm (TAP) Q1 2022 Earnings Name Transcript

May 3, 2022
15 Personal Growth Questions To Ask Yourself

15 Personal Growth Questions To Ask Yourself

January 27, 2023
Jacob Howland on the Hidden Human Costs of AI

Jacob Howland on the Hidden Human Costs of AI

June 27, 2023
Index Investing News

Get the latest news and follow the coverage of Investing, World News, Stocks, Market Analysis, Business & Financial News, and more from the top trusted sources.

  • 1717575246.7
  • Browse the latest news about investing and more
  • Contact us
  • Cookie Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • DMCA
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • xtw18387b488

Copyright © 2022 - Index Investing News.
Index Investing News is not responsible for the content of external sites.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • World
  • Investing
  • Financial
  • Economy
  • Markets
  • Stocks
  • Crypto
  • Property
  • Sport
  • Entertainment
  • Opinion

Copyright © 2022 - Index Investing News.
Index Investing News is not responsible for the content of external sites.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In