Quitting Qatar is the least of Hamas’s issues

The spacious beige villas in Doha’s northern suburbs have been as soon as dwelling to most of the senior leaders of Hamas, the Palestinian Islamists. However they’ve largely been empty in current months. For the reason that final spherical of American- and Qatari-mediated talks with Israel collapsed in August, the Qataris, as soon as welcoming, have cooled on Hamas. The group’s remaining bosses have been spending extra time in Turkey, the place Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s authorities has obtained them extra warmly.

Qatari officers say current studies that they’re planning to evict Hamas are “inaccurate”, however sources near the group’s leaders concede that with a brand new American president, they could not be capable to hold their political headquarters there for much longer. “We’re simply being prudent,” says the son of a member of the group’s politburo of their sojourns in Istanbul.

After the assaults of October seventh, Hamas appeared triumphant. At this time its base in Gaza has been destroyed, its management decapitated and it appears more and more homeless. Even because the conflict grinds on, extra Gazans are keen to talk out in opposition to the Islamists, blaming them for unleashing Israel’s anger and its devastating conflict. Anti-Hamas protests have been uncommon earlier than the battle; they’ve change into a bit extra frequent. Salman al-Dayah, a number one Islamic scholar in Gaza, lately revealed a coruscating fatwa accusing Hamas of “violating Islamic ideas” when it endangered its personal civilians by attacking Israel.

Over the previous ten months Hamas has misplaced its three most distinguished figures: its chief in Gaza, Yahya Sinwar, and its senior political leaders, Ismail Haniyeh and Saleh al-Arouri. The group is now led by a quartet of squabbling officers primarily based outdoors Gaza, who’re retaining a low profile for concern of assassination, and the remnants of the navy wing’s commanders in Gaza.

Its two major patrons now view it as a legal responsibility greater than an asset. Iran sees Hamas as having dragged it and its proxy, Hizbullah, into an endless cycle of warfare with Israel. The Qataris nonetheless give the group a platform on Al Jazeera, a state-sponsored satellite tv for pc channel. However they’re coming underneath rising stress from the Individuals to indicate that they nonetheless wield affect over Hamas, or to kick it out (Qatar additionally hosts main American bases).

All through many of the conflict, a ceasefire in Gaza was seen as the important thing to bringing some type of peace to the area. That has modified. American-brokered talks for a deal in Lebanon are actually extra superior. Iran can be anxious to discover a technique to stop extra Israeli air strikes which jeopardise its economic system and inner stability. If these goals might be achieved, Hamas might be disregarded within the chilly.

Hamas maintains that it’s going to conform to a ceasefire and launch the remaining 101 Israeli hostages (half of whom are presumed lifeless) solely when Israel commits to a full withdrawal from Gaza. That is trying more and more unlikely. Israeli forces have expanded their maintain on three widening strips of territory, and are pushing many of the inhabitants right into a “humanitarian zone” within the south, the place most will spend a second terrible winter in tents. And Israel’s leaders are unlikely to make any concessions till after Donald Trump’s inauguration.

If Hamas refuses to indicate any flexibility in negotiations and is evicted from Qatar, will probably be left with few alternate options. Decamping to Tehran would enhance its dependence on Iran. Iraq, one other majority-Shia nation, is likely to be an uncomfortable base for the Sunnis of Hamas. Damascus and Beirut are inside straightforward attain of Israel’s safety providers, which have vowed to seek out these chargeable for the October seventh massacres. Turkey could be the solely choice, however even Mr Erdogan, because the chief of a member of nato, has to maintain up appearances. “There gained’t be a brass plate on the door,” says one Western official in Doha. Surveillance will likely be much more “strong”.

Deserted by its allies, resented by Gazans and nonetheless underneath assault from Israel, dropping its comfy outpost in Doha could be the least of Hamas’s issues.

© 2025, The Economist Newspaper Restricted. All rights reserved. From The Economist, revealed underneath licence. The unique content material might be discovered on www.economist.com