Index Investing News
Wednesday, May 28, 2025
No Result
View All Result
  • Login
  • Home
  • World
  • Investing
  • Financial
  • Economy
  • Markets
  • Stocks
  • Crypto
  • Property
  • Sport
  • Entertainment
  • Opinion
  • Home
  • World
  • Investing
  • Financial
  • Economy
  • Markets
  • Stocks
  • Crypto
  • Property
  • Sport
  • Entertainment
  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
Index Investing News
No Result
View All Result

Litigation by or against trustees – who can act?

by Index Investing News
June 29, 2022
in Opinion
Reading Time: 4 mins read
A A
0
Home Opinion
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter



Litigation by or against trustees – who can act?

A trust itself cannot sue or be sued, because it is not recognised as a legal persona, but rather a legal persona sui generis (which means of its own kind or class), in South Africa (Rosner v Lydia Swanepoel Trust case of 1998).

The trustees, in their official capacity, can, however, sue or be sued.

All the trustees must join in suing and all must be sued (Mariola v Kaye-Eddie case of 1995).

Therefore when a trust is sued or sues, the names of all trustees, rather than the trust itself, are to be sited in pleadings.

Even though the names of the trustees will be cited in any action against a trust, it is the trust that will be liable in respect of any claims and not the trustees personally; the trustees merely act in their official capacities as trustees of the trust.

As a general rule, the proper persons to act on behalf of a trust are the trustees, and not the beneficiaries, as they do not have locus standi (a right to appear in a court or before any body, or a right to be heard) (Gross v Pentz case of 1996).

Not even a beneficiary’s interest in the trust is sufficient to create locus standi to institute proceedings against parties dealing with a trust, other than against trustees, to protect or recover trust assets (Mariola v Kaye-Eddie case of 1995).

The Gross v Pentz case of 1996, where a trustee has alledgedly disposed of a trust asset below its market value, causing financial loss to the trust, resulting in an action in respect of maladministration of the trust, amounting to a breach of trust and resulting in a monetary loss to the trust, confirmed that there are two types of actions that can be taken:

  1. “Representative actions” – actions brought on behalf of the trust, including:
  • to recover trust assets; or
  • to nullify transactions entered into by the trust; or
  • to recover damages from a third party

The general rule described above applies to these actions. If the trustees properly authorise one of them before action is instituted, then that trustee can act on behalf of the others (Mariola v Kaye-Eddie case of 1995).

If one of the trustees, not so authorised, has initiated litigation, his or her actions can be ratified later, subject to the requirement that such trustee had the capacity to act – he or she was authorised by the Master of the High Court in terms of Section 6 of the Trust Property Control Act and the required minimum number of trustees were in office as stipulated in the trust instrument (Pieters Family Trust v PW Colyn case of 2006).

  1. “Direct actions” – actions brought by a beneficiary in his, her or its own right against a trustee for one of the following:
  • maladministration of trust assets, resulting in a loss to the beneficiary; or
  • failure to pay or transfer to a beneficiary what is due to him, her or it under the trust; or
  • paying to or transferring to one beneficiary what is not due to him, her or it

The Court held that only beneficiaries with vested rights can bring a direct action and not a beneficiary with merely a contingent right to income and/or capital (Estate Bazley v Estate Arnott case of 1931).

This is because a discretionary/contingent beneficiary will be unable to show that he, she or it personally sustained financial loss, as such beneficiary merely has a ‘spes’ (hope) to receive something from the trust in future.

The best such a beneficiary could do is to motivate that the trust sustained a loss as a result of some maladministration, which may result in such beneficiary receiving less in future from the trust, as a result of the diminution of trust assets.

Although the general rule normally applies, in this case the Court however applied the exception to the general rule and allowed the beneficiary to bring the action, as a defaulting trustee cannot be expected to sue himself (this is called the “Beningfield exception” (Benningfield v Baxter case of 1886)) – it therefore modified the general rule, which allowed the beneficiary to bring a representative action as an exception. It allowed the discretionary beneficiary to bring the case, as it believed that all beneficiaries have a vested interest in the proper administration of the trust.

The Court therefore confirmed that the beneficiary had the requisite locus to institute the application (this was also confirmed in the July v Mbuqe case of 2017).

The Court held that the only alternative to allowing the Benningfield exception would be to require the aggrieved beneficiary to sue for the removal of the trustee and the appointment of a replacement trustee with the hope that the new trustee would bring action against the removed trustee for the recovery of the trust’s assets, or other relief for the recoupment of the loss sustained by the trust.

This would impose too cumbersome a process upon the aggrieved beneficiary.

The Benningfield exception would however only apply when a beneficiary had no recourse to direct action against the defaulting trustee (Breetzke v Alexander case of 2015).

Phia van der Spuy. File Image: IOL

Phia van der Spuy is a Master Tax Practitioner (SA)™, a Trust and Estate Practitioner (TEP) and the founder of Trusteeze®, a professional trust practitioner.

BUSINESS REPORT



Source link

Tags: actLitigationtrustees
ShareTweetShareShare
Previous Post

Toshakhana items: Ex-PM Imran Khan earned Rs 36 million from promoting three gifted watches to native seller

Next Post

Sentient chatbot hires its own lawyer

Related Posts

French prez Macron claims he fell down stairs once more

French prez Macron claims he fell down stairs once more

by Index Investing News
May 28, 2025
0

Each week, The Put up will convey you our picks of the very best one-liners and tales from satirical website...

Wanted: A tough coverage reset to make Indian banks form up

Wanted: A tough coverage reset to make Indian banks form up

by Index Investing News
May 28, 2025
0

This doesn’t sit effectively with India’s picture as a excessive potential tech-savvy economic system. We'd like a extremely environment friendly...

Trump’s Missile Protect Will Cease Conflict Earlier than It Begins – FREEDOMBUNKER

Trump’s Missile Protect Will Cease Conflict Earlier than It Begins – FREEDOMBUNKER

by Index Investing News
May 28, 2025
0

Authored by Corinne Clark Bannon by way of AmericanGreatness.com,President Donald J. Trump has formally introduced plans to construct a next-generation...

Antisemitic DC killings have to be a wake-up name for NYC voters

Antisemitic DC killings have to be a wake-up name for NYC voters

by Index Investing News
May 27, 2025
0

Final week’s horrific murders in Washington, DC, can solely additional feed the backlash towards rising antisemitism already brewing in subsequent...

Trump Accounts? Republicans Have Had Higher Concepts

Trump Accounts? Republicans Have Had Higher Concepts

by Index Investing News
May 27, 2025
0

The Republican tax invoice accommodates flashy goodies for households with youngsters. The flashiest: financial savings accounts for kids — branded Trump...

Next Post
Sentient chatbot hires its own lawyer

Sentient chatbot hires its own lawyer

Basic Mills, Carnival, Mattress Bathtub & Past and extra

Basic Mills, Carnival, Mattress Bathtub & Past and extra

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

RECOMMENDED

Milken Institute discusses report on China’s ‘best-performing’ cities

Milken Institute discusses report on China’s ‘best-performing’ cities

September 3, 2024
Prime 3 Palisades Tahoe Ski Lease Funding Alternatives

Prime 3 Palisades Tahoe Ski Lease Funding Alternatives

August 12, 2024
Tesla Earnings Are Coming. Watch What Elon Musk, Management Says.

Tesla Earnings Are Coming. Watch What Elon Musk, Management Says.

April 19, 2023
Israel Could Face Further Legal Action For Non-Compliance of ICJ Ruling — Global Issues

Israel Could Face Further Legal Action For Non-Compliance of ICJ Ruling — Global Issues

February 2, 2024
Royal Tungsten eyes up international expansion under new Global Marketing head.

Royal Tungsten eyes up international expansion under new Global Marketing head.

July 12, 2022
Renters Are Still Moving—These Markets Are Where You Should Be Investing

Renters Are Still Moving—These Markets Are Where You Should Be Investing

March 7, 2024
When does the 2023 November international break end?

When does the 2023 November international break end?

November 13, 2023
Atara sees filing for FDA approval of Tab-cel in Q2 2024 (ATRA)

Atara sees filing for FDA approval of Tab-cel in Q2 2024 (ATRA)

September 19, 2023
Index Investing News

Get the latest news and follow the coverage of Investing, World News, Stocks, Market Analysis, Business & Financial News, and more from the top trusted sources.

  • 1717575246.7
  • Browse the latest news about investing and more
  • Contact us
  • Cookie Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • DMCA
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • xtw18387b488

Copyright © 2022 - Index Investing News.
Index Investing News is not responsible for the content of external sites.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • World
  • Investing
  • Financial
  • Economy
  • Markets
  • Stocks
  • Crypto
  • Property
  • Sport
  • Entertainment
  • Opinion

Copyright © 2022 - Index Investing News.
Index Investing News is not responsible for the content of external sites.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In