Index Investing News
Sunday, May 25, 2025
No Result
View All Result
  • Login
  • Home
  • World
  • Investing
  • Financial
  • Economy
  • Markets
  • Stocks
  • Crypto
  • Property
  • Sport
  • Entertainment
  • Opinion
  • Home
  • World
  • Investing
  • Financial
  • Economy
  • Markets
  • Stocks
  • Crypto
  • Property
  • Sport
  • Entertainment
  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
Index Investing News
No Result
View All Result

India must develop a scientific temper

by Index Investing News
March 22, 2023
in Opinion
Reading Time: 4 mins read
A A
0
Home Opinion
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


India is not a developing nation. It was once at the pinnacle of development, fell, and is rising again. Thus, we have valuable traditional knowledge that is yet to undergo modern scientific evaluation and is not considered evidence-based. In the realm of health, ayurveda is rich in sustainable living practices that are now being echoed by modern medicine. For example, it emphasises gut health and various health properties of food types and cooking methods; modern science has only recently caught up with how diet and gut microbiomes impact health.

We need to articulate the boundaries of scientific possibilities during collaborations, revisit them frequently, and consider new knowledge (Shutterstock) PREMIUM
We need to articulate the boundaries of scientific possibilities during collaborations, revisit them frequently, and consider new knowledge (Shutterstock)

But traditional wisdom can be tainted with superstitions and misconceptions that must be filtered for individual and social harm. In medicine, the burden of proof is high due to the potential human costs of wrong advice. Increasing cases of liver injury in otherwise healthy people due to herbal supplements of dubious benefit is a case in point. The best approach is healthy scepticism, where we are open to new ideas, irrespective of the source, but question them rigorously.

Any unproven new idea of seeming benefit should be tested against a three-pronged benchmark. First, scientific plausibility. Second, consideration of harm. And third, given the scientific probability, the possibility of generation of evidence towards incorporation into scientific medical practice. Pursuing truth via science and the scientific method is the essence of future integrative medical science. Such a pathway has been recommended by many organisations, ranging from those who debunk superstitions to those who are guiding the transformation of India, such as the NITI Aayog. However, this can be challenging.

Recently, media reports chronicled an integrative medicine meeting of maternal and child health practitioners, including senior faculty from the All Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS), Delhi, my alma mater. Troublingly, the narrative seems to have been non-scientific in some parts. The idea that gender expectations of mothers could lead to homosexuality in children — for example, a pregnant woman wanting a girl child may cause a male child to grow up as homosexual — is laughable. Suggestions that women follow the example of Jija Bai’s prayers during pregnancy so that they may have children with qualities of “Hindu rulers” is disturbing. There were also discussions on the importance of studying the scriptures during pregnancy and how children of modern parents were increasingly being born with birth disorders and autism, due to a lack of sanskar (cultural traditions). This thinking is wrong at many scientific, social and ethical levels. So, how do we move forward to ensure that the final integrative whole is not less than the sum of its parts?

Many ayurveda colleagues dismissed this discussion as a distorted fringe-element version of garbha sanskar, which speaks of the importance of healthy practices during pregnancy as determinants of future child health, perhaps via epigenetic influences. While most members of an alum group of AIIMS-trained doctors were alarmed at these media reports, a few considered such thinking or practices harmless. They rationalised that people can take the good parts of such reports and discard the rest. In their view, the absence of evidence is not evidence of absence, and that we should not be too critical of traditions. While the second approach may superficially seem more conducive to integrative research in India, I differ.

Ayurgenomics, an intersection of ayurvedic concepts and genomic investigations, was successfully led by my former institute (CSIR-IGIB) because we had honest scientific discussions where we could set evidence challenges for the ayurveda team.

When experts on one side choose not to question the other, it is disingenuous and is likely to lead to long-term harm. We need to articulate the boundaries of scientific possibilities during collaborations, revisit them frequently, and consider new knowledge. This accelerates meaningful collaboration and culls the meaningless ones. Beyond this, we need to view all output in the context of the realities of our heterogeneous society, where women often face the consequences of misinformation.

Wrong beliefs articulated by senior experts have consequences. In the example above, such discussions will either lead to the mother being blamed for the different abilities or sexual orientation of the child, or even put societal pressure on pregnant women. Every doctor should be aware of the traditional blaming of women for their child’s gender. It is disconcerting when doctors cannot connect misinformation propagation to such social ills. For a country where Article 51 A(h) of the Constitution makes it a fundamental duty to develop scientific temper, humanism and the spirit of inquiry and reform, much needs to be done by medical professionals.

To question or challenge a practice, a senior or a teacher is considered disrespectful in India, including in modern medical institutions. Consequently, we have too much faith and not enough scientific temper. That must change. Only after setting our house in order will we have the confidence to engage with others, scientifically questioning their practices in the same hard way we do ourselves. In the end, there is no magic, it’s all science.

Anurag Agrawal is dean, BioSciences and Health Research, Trivedi School of Biosciences, Ashoka University The views expressed are personal



Source link

Tags: developIndiaScientifictemper
ShareTweetShareShare
Previous Post

Target Hospitality: Strong Revenue Growth Continues (NASDAQ:TH)

Next Post

Action Thriller ‘Hunt Club’ Trailer with Mena Suvari & Casper Van Dien

Related Posts

The DC Israeli Embassy staffer killings are what occurs when phrases grow to be weapons

The DC Israeli Embassy staffer killings are what occurs when phrases grow to be weapons

by Index Investing News
May 25, 2025
0

Phrases have penalties. Lethal phrases have lethal penalties. Two workers members of the Israeli Embassy in Washington, Sarah Milgrim, 26,...

Well being Speak: Why CBSE’s transfer to have sugar boards in colleges is wholesome

Well being Speak: Why CBSE’s transfer to have sugar boards in colleges is wholesome

by Index Investing News
May 25, 2025
0

A brand new Central Board of Secondary Schooling (CBSE) directive has requested colleges affiliated to it throughout the nation to...

Authorities-Assisted Suicide Is Spreading Throughout The Western World – FREEDOMBUNKER

Authorities-Assisted Suicide Is Spreading Throughout The Western World – FREEDOMBUNKER

by Index Investing News
May 24, 2025
0

Is it humanitarian empathy, or a nihilistic demise cult that wishes a authorized rationale for inhabitants management?  The legislative push...

‘Advance tipping’ on ride-hailing apps is merely a symptom of lax legislation enforcement

‘Advance tipping’ on ride-hailing apps is merely a symptom of lax legislation enforcement

by Index Investing News
May 24, 2025
0

In a publish on X final week Pralhad Joshi wrote, “Forcing or nudging customers to pay a tip upfront for...

The issue with utilizing the phrase ‘plantation’ –
Las Vegas Solar Information

The issue with utilizing the phrase ‘plantation’ – Las Vegas Solar Information

by Index Investing News
May 24, 2025
0

Saturday, Could 24, 2025 | 2 a.m. The biggest remaining antebellum plantation mansion within the South has burned to the...

Next Post
Action Thriller ‘Hunt Club’ Trailer with Mena Suvari & Casper Van Dien

Action Thriller 'Hunt Club' Trailer with Mena Suvari & Casper Van Dien

Monthly Dividend Stock In Focus: Paramount Resources

Monthly Dividend Stock In Focus: Paramount Resources

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

RECOMMENDED

‘Genuine prospect of Palestinian statehood is critical’, UNRWA chief tells emergency summit in Saudi Arabia — Global Issues

‘Genuine prospect of Palestinian statehood is critical’, UNRWA chief tells emergency summit in Saudi Arabia — Global Issues

November 12, 2023
Republic of Ireland 0-1 Switzerland: John O’Shea’s interim spell as manager ends in defeat | Football News

Republic of Ireland 0-1 Switzerland: John O’Shea’s interim spell as manager ends in defeat | Football News

March 27, 2024
Finish slaughter of state’s wildlife

Finish slaughter of state’s wildlife

October 4, 2024
The mainstream media lied to me about conservatives

The mainstream media lied to me about conservatives

October 31, 2022
DCP Midstream: Poised For Near-Term Growth But Be Cautious Buying (NYSE:DCP)

DCP Midstream: Poised For Near-Term Growth But Be Cautious Buying (NYSE:DCP)

August 28, 2022
Teamsters reach deal with UPS, avoiding major strike

Teamsters reach deal with UPS, avoiding major strike

July 25, 2023
IRS Lagging In Complying With Order Not To Increase Audit Charges For Underneath-0,000 Earners: Watchdog – FREEDOMBUNKER

IRS Lagging In Complying With Order Not To Increase Audit Charges For Underneath-$400,000 Earners: Watchdog – FREEDOMBUNKER

September 1, 2024
.7 Million Homes in California

$2.7 Million Homes in California

September 25, 2023
Index Investing News

Get the latest news and follow the coverage of Investing, World News, Stocks, Market Analysis, Business & Financial News, and more from the top trusted sources.

  • 1717575246.7
  • Browse the latest news about investing and more
  • Contact us
  • Cookie Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • DMCA
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • xtw18387b488

Copyright © 2022 - Index Investing News.
Index Investing News is not responsible for the content of external sites.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • World
  • Investing
  • Financial
  • Economy
  • Markets
  • Stocks
  • Crypto
  • Property
  • Sport
  • Entertainment
  • Opinion

Copyright © 2022 - Index Investing News.
Index Investing News is not responsible for the content of external sites.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In