Index Investing News
Thursday, May 29, 2025
No Result
View All Result
  • Login
  • Home
  • World
  • Investing
  • Financial
  • Economy
  • Markets
  • Stocks
  • Crypto
  • Property
  • Sport
  • Entertainment
  • Opinion
  • Home
  • World
  • Investing
  • Financial
  • Economy
  • Markets
  • Stocks
  • Crypto
  • Property
  • Sport
  • Entertainment
  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
Index Investing News
No Result
View All Result

Hijaab: Let the liberty of individual conscience prevail

by Index Investing News
October 18, 2022
in Opinion
Reading Time: 6 mins read
A A
0
Home Opinion
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


In Karnataka, Sikh boys can wear turbans, Hindu boys can wear the sacred thread or a rudraksh, girls can wear mangalsutras and bindis, but Muslim girls cannot wear a hijaab to school, for it is banned by a policy that governs uniforms. Does the school have the right to impose a uniform on children and insist on its enforcement? Of course. But can the school adopt a policy that directly impacts the conscience rights of one community and not others? Should the religious and conscience rights under the Indian Constitution extend to reasonable accommodation in secular matters on issues such as uniforms, the National Anthem, etc? These are the real questions that arise in the hijaab case, and it is a sign of the peculiar state of religious-rights jurisprudence in India that they were not dealt with in the Karnataka high court’s ruling and did not form part of the 11 questions at least one of the recent Supreme Court (SC) judgements tasked itself with answering.

Under Article 25(1), persons are entitled to freedom of conscience and the right to freely profess, practise and propagate religion, subject to public order, morality, health and the fundamental rights of other persons. Under Article 25(2), economic, financial, political or secular activities relating to religious practice can be regulated, and in particular social welfare and reform measures are permissible. Article 26(b) grants the right to religious denominations to manage their affairs in matters of religion, subject to public order, morality and health. Thus 25(1) protects an individual’s rights while 26(b) and 25(2) deal with community rights. Naturally then, the considerations that apply when courts are faced with a claim of individual conscience are quite different from a community claim about what a religion says. When a court has to consider which practices can be ameliorated by social reform legislation or can be regulated by secular law, it may need to examine religious doctrines to see if the practice is “essential” or not, the logic being that an essential feature of a religion cannot be legislated away. The same logic cannot apply when the court is faced with individual claims of conscience. Simply put, freedom of conscience means that no authority sits in judgement on an individual’s beliefs to decide what is worthy of protection and what is not. How would this apply in the hijaab case? When the court examines a case of girls who wish to wear a hijaab as a matter of conscience, it is not for the court to check the theological or Quranic basis for it. The only issue is how the conscience right to wear one can be reconciled with the uniform policy of a school.

Unlike France, India has always made reasonable accommodation for religious or cultural practices. Girl students, for example, are frequently permitted to choose between skirts and salwar kameez, just as boys are permitted turbans or sacred threads. If a school girl is allowed a traditional dupatta, what disciplinary problem is caused if this garment is wrapped around the head instead?

The judgement of Justice Hemant Gupta is a paean to the noble school uniform, meant to treat students as equals, with any breach taken as a discipline issue. But this frame is difficult to accept per se, considering that Sikh turbans are acceptable under the uniform policy. Accordingly, the judgement tries to distinguish between the claims of various denominations of faith in order to show how the hijaab alone can be banned. Turbans are fine as they are an essential religious practice for Sikhs, the rudraksh is fine as it is worn beneath the uniform (thus isn’t part of policy). The hijaab alone violates discipline. That this policy disproportionately impacts Muslims is not considered, as the policy is secular on the face of it. This is a victory of form over substance that belies innumerable court precedents. The principle of reasonable accommodation finds no purchase in this ruling and foreign precedents are not dealt with because India is different. This would surprise judges of the SC who laid down the law on religious rights in the celebrated 1954 Shirur matth case judgement.

The other half of the split verdict, Justice Sudhanshu Dhulia’s judgement correctly identifies the issue as one of a conscience right, and a part of free expression, to which the essential practice test does not apply. This judgement goes on correctly to view this case as being covered by the National Anthem case, where Jehovah’s Witnesses were permitted to be exempt from singing the anthem as a reasonable accommodation. The judgement talks about dignity, freedom and privacy, and holds that these values are not surrendered at the altar of discipline at the school gate. The ruling recognizes the fact that the issue must be seen in the light of girls’ struggle to make it to school at all and whether such a policy makes it harder. It also talks about fraternity and diversity, and the idea of constitutional trust that minorities place in the majority.

In the end, the issue is quite simple, as the Justice Dhulia judgement makes clear. The most important thing is that children should be educated. Uniform policies should accommodate religious and conscience-related exceptions for all faiths because that would advance the cause of education and because respect for all religions and individual conscience is the hallmark of our constitutional tradition. Allowing the hijaab is not an issue of discipline, but about according equal respect to all religions. The essential religious practices test is irrelevant to the issue at hand.

Justice Dhulia’s judgement is a victory for constitutionalism and should be applauded as such. It merits being reaffirmed whenever a larger bench of the SC settles the issue.

Rahul Narayan is advocate on record, Supreme Court of India, and solicitor, England and Wales

Catch all the Business News, Market News, Breaking News Events and Latest News Updates on Live Mint.
Download The Mint News App to get Daily Market Updates.

More
Less



Source link

Tags: conscienceHijaabindividualLibertyPrevail
ShareTweetShareShare
Previous Post

PhonePe’s operating revenue jumps more than double in FY22

Next Post

Benjamin Mendy trial: Court hears woman had ‘sex with Jack Grealish’ and another man on night she was ‘raped by Mendy’s friend’ | Football News

Related Posts

The left’s assassination fixation solely additional normalizes political violence

The left’s assassination fixation solely additional normalizes political violence

by Index Investing News
May 29, 2025
0

The left’s assassination obsession is escalating alarmingly and is being tacitly endorsed in all of the unsuitable locations. Some, like...

“I Know You Share My Concern” – FREEDOMBUNKER

“I Know You Share My Concern” – FREEDOMBUNKER

by Index Investing News
May 28, 2025
0

Authored by Ibrahim Garza through The Faculty Repair,A Yale College dean emailed your complete Divinity College a replica of his MSNBC...

French prez Macron claims he fell down stairs once more

French prez Macron claims he fell down stairs once more

by Index Investing News
May 28, 2025
0

Each week, The Put up will convey you our picks of the very best one-liners and tales from satirical website...

Siddharth Pai: Arm workers in opposition to subtle cyberattacks

Siddharth Pai: Arm workers in opposition to subtle cyberattacks

by Index Investing News
May 29, 2025
0

A hacker group generally known as Scattered Spider is being probed for breaching M&S’s programs via a third-party IT providers...

Putin could be deterred by reviving the ‘Reforger’ –
Las Vegas Solar Information

Putin could be deterred by reviving the ‘Reforger’ – Las Vegas Solar Information

by Index Investing News
May 28, 2025
0

Wednesday, Could 28, 2025 | 2 a.m. Once I was a junior officer through the Chilly Warfare, the largest North...

Next Post
Benjamin Mendy trial: Court hears woman had ‘sex with Jack Grealish’ and another man on night she was ‘raped by Mendy’s friend’ | Football News

Benjamin Mendy trial: Court hears woman had 'sex with Jack Grealish' and another man on night she was 'raped by Mendy's friend' | Football News

Still much work left | Mint

Still much work left | Mint

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

RECOMMENDED

Clearing the Air on Tariffs and Commerce Deficits

Clearing the Air on Tariffs and Commerce Deficits

April 26, 2025
Britain has ‘troublesome 48 hours’ forward with 1st-ever excessive warmth warning

Britain has ‘troublesome 48 hours’ forward with 1st-ever excessive warmth warning

July 18, 2022
Destructive Energy Policies in the United States and California

Destructive Energy Policies in the United States and California

June 8, 2023
Manhattan Beach Estate With Celebrity Pedigree—Think ‘Modern Family’ And Shaq—Sells For .5 Million

Manhattan Beach Estate With Celebrity Pedigree—Think ‘Modern Family’ And Shaq—Sells For $10.5 Million

June 9, 2023
Information Roundup: Hearings, hearings! Jan. 6 hearings!

Information Roundup: Hearings, hearings! Jan. 6 hearings!

June 11, 2022
Might was the slowest month in jobs restoration as personal payrolls elevated by simply 128,000

Might was the slowest month in jobs restoration as personal payrolls elevated by simply 128,000

June 2, 2022
Denver Market Traits

Denver Market Traits

June 7, 2022
Starboard takes a stake in Qorvo. How the activist could assist enhance margins

Starboard takes a stake in Qorvo. How the activist could assist enhance margins

January 25, 2025
Index Investing News

Get the latest news and follow the coverage of Investing, World News, Stocks, Market Analysis, Business & Financial News, and more from the top trusted sources.

  • 1717575246.7
  • Browse the latest news about investing and more
  • Contact us
  • Cookie Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • DMCA
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • xtw18387b488

Copyright © 2022 - Index Investing News.
Index Investing News is not responsible for the content of external sites.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • World
  • Investing
  • Financial
  • Economy
  • Markets
  • Stocks
  • Crypto
  • Property
  • Sport
  • Entertainment
  • Opinion

Copyright © 2022 - Index Investing News.
Index Investing News is not responsible for the content of external sites.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In