Has Pep Guardiola’s fashion of soccer develop into outdated – or is it extra sophisticated than that?

Manchester Metropolis are having a nasty season, there is no such thing as a doubt about that. However there’s a distinction of opinion in relation to deciding why that is the case.

Your extra informal observer would possibly put it all the way down to Rodri’s absence with a long-term knee harm, and naturally there may be loads of reality in that.

Maybe you’re pitching it someplace within the center, nodding sagely about a number of components. Sure, Rodri’s harm was the primary domino to fall nevertheless it uncovered an “outdated” midfield — in Pep Guardiola’s phrases — and a defence fully blighted by accidents.

However there may be one other faculty of thought, one that appears past Metropolis’s borders. What if Guardiola’s total taking part in fashion is turning into outdated?

It is a idea that has gone mainstream over the previous couple of months, warranting a dialogue on in style debate present The Overlap and an in-depth article on the BBC Sport web site.

“Right now, fashionable soccer is the way in which that Bournemouth play, that Newcastle play, Brighton play, Liverpool have at all times been like that, like we had been,” Guardiola stated himself in an interview with TNT on the finish of final yr. “It’s fashionable soccer. Fashionable soccer shouldn’t be so positional.”

Positional, in fact, neatly describes Guardiola’s total strategy — ‘juego de posicion’, as it’s recognized in Spanish — and that remark was the one picked up for the dialog on The Overlap: right here is Guardiola suggesting that fashionable soccer is shifting away from his fashion, so perhaps that’s the reason Metropolis have struggled a lot over latest months, shedding 15 of their final 30 matches.

That was the theme of the BBC article following Metropolis’s tepid efficiency on the Santiago Bernabeu, the place it was recommended that their points this season — injured, ageing gamers, underperforming stars, low confidence — had been signs, not causes.

Throughout discussions about this topic on-line, it was highlighted that Metropolis’s fashion of play could be very completely different to the remainder of the league. And it’s. However right here’s the factor: it at all times has been.

In earlier seasons, their very completely different strategy in comparison with the remainder of the league has been held up as a purpose for his or her dominance. Their slower fashion has been seen as a part of the rationale why they management video games. Because the chart above reveals, Metropolis’s fashion this season is definitely not an outlier within the Guardiola period.

So it feels a little bit reductive to say the fashion is not working now that Metropolis are usually not doing effectively. Given there are such a lot of apparent components — accidents, low confidence, stalwarts like Kevin De Bruyne, Bernardo Silva and Ilkay Gundogan taking part in effectively under their greatest — is it not affordable to say that these issues have made the fashion much less efficient, in the identical approach that any staff, taking part in any fashion, would most likely be struggling as effectively?

And this was Guardiola’s level in that TNT interview, not that the league is getting away from Metropolis.

“We have now to rise to the rhythm unbelievably,” he additionally stated, “and we couldn’t, merely we couldn’t as a result of we didn’t have the gamers.”

He goes on to reference the quantity of accidents at golf equipment round Europe and eventually gives an answer to the issues going through his facet this yr… and it didn’t relate to taking part in fashion.

“I mirror that sooner or later we’ve to (have) an extended squad,” he stated. “I at all times believed (it must be accomplished) with few gamers, however with that the staff can’t survive.”

Solely final season he did certainly say he would “somewhat not be a supervisor” than to have an enormous squad however that has modified this season, and whereas he did talk about the altering face of the Premier League in that interview, he feels that the answer is to not rip up his fashion, however to firstly get his gamers again match and secondly to make sure they keep match by having extra choices.

The message is obvious: take the accidents out of the equation and his fashion would nonetheless work.

Oscar Bobb has been a significant loss for Guardiola this season (Stu Forster/Getty Photographs)

He could also be improper concerning the continued effectiveness of his personal fashion, and he would most likely not admit it even when he felt it, however it could be improper to counsel, based mostly on what he stated on the finish of final yr, that he thinks Metropolis are being left behind.

The dialogue has additionally seemingly disregarded Metropolis’s personal evolution over the previous couple of years, which was one thing else that Guardiola talked about in that interview.

When giving examples of different groups’ direct strategy, he additionally included Metropolis: “Like we had been”.

He was requested about this just lately, too, and he spoke at size concerning the modifications within the league, in addition to those self same two factors: that the accidents have undermined Metropolis’s season and that they’ve been evolving with the occasions anyway.

“I noticed personally that extra groups like taking part in extra man-to-man, extra aggressive in your build-up, a couple of of them play like this,” he stated. “By way of being extra direct, English soccer has been extra direct (eternally), it has at all times been, ‘Don’t play a lot within the center and play lengthy balls’.

“However within the final years loads of groups play from behind, Tottenham is an instance and lots of, many different groups.”

He then highlighted a course of that Metropolis went by in 2022-23; initially that season once they struggled in opposition to groups that pressed them man-to-man, however they step by step grew to become simpler as a result of they embraced lengthy balls to Erling Haaland. One thing that has been seen this season, too, most notably in opposition to Chelsea in January.

Guardiola is assured his staff can return to the highest (Michael Regan/Getty Photographs)

“Usually, whenever you make a positional sport in opposition to man-to-man it’s fully completely different however we dealt with ourselves very well in opposition to groups who play man-to-man, we aren’t involved about that,” he continued, after which he received to the largest problem with this season, in his eyes.

“It’s extra… at all times we’ve the remorse this season, I stated many occasions, ‘What would have occurred with (solely) one, two, three muscular accidents throughout the season, three or 4 weeks out?’ However we’ve central defenders (who’re) eight, 10 weeks out, we don’t have Rodri for six or seven months, Oscar (Bobb) is 5, six months out.

“I can think about we’d have been extra aggressive than we’ve been, however when we’ve the squad we will play in that approach. We will do it.

“Whereas I’m the supervisor, we’re going to regulate one thing relying on the standard of the gamers or the issues that the opponents (pose) however I feel we’re going to attempt to play the way in which that outlined the staff for a few years, that had success.

“The one distinction is that there are extra groups that (do) man-marking in our purpose kick, they’re extra aggressive. Earlier than they had been extra cautious. Now groups are so courageous, that could be a little bit completely different. I might say that’s the just one, the remaining… in the event you had your staff you possibly can compete and you possibly can play the way in which we’ve performed previously.”

Rodri’s long-term absence continues to solid a shadow over Metropolis’s season (Michael Regan/Getty Photographs)

It’s one thing Metropolis have tailored to, whilst they keep their general extra affected person, slower strategy in most video games. The change could not put them nearer to the opposite groups within the graphics as a result of the vast majority of opponents nonetheless sit deep in opposition to Metropolis, and once they try this, Guardiola instructs his gamers to “take a espresso”, to make extra passes and be extra affected person, to keep away from counter-attacks.

That strategy has been sufficient to win the title previously 4 seasons, so why would it not have out of the blue stopped? Is it as a result of it’s not efficient, or as a result of the gamers — for myriad causes — haven’t been capable of implement it correctly?

(Header photograph: Justin Setterfield/Getty Photographs)