Index fund investors have various choices when selecting the weighting style of the funds they hold. There are market cap-weighted indices like the S&P 500 and the Russell 2000/3000, stock price-weighted indices like the Dow Jones Industrial Average, as well as equally weighted indices.
But to our knowledge, there is no index constructed at the US country level that weights holdings by each sector’s underlying GDP.
So, how would we construct such an index and how would it compare to the S&P 500 in terms of performance and risk?
To create our US GDP-weighted index, we broke the S&P 500 down into its 11 underlying sectors and pulled the data for each sector’s corresponding Vanguard exchange-traded fund (ETF) going back to 2005. Next, we took each sector’s contribution to GDP at the start of each quarter and calculated each sector’s GDP contribution over the subsequent quarter and multiplied that by the sector’s relative GDP weight at the start of the quarter. That gave us the sector’s contribution to the index’s overall return over that quarter.
For instance, if Financials contributed 10.95% to US GDP in the first quarter of 2015 and the Vanguard Financials ETF (VHF) declined 0.81% that quarter, then by our calculation — 10.95% * –0.81% — the Financials industry contributed –0.089% to the overall GDP-weighted index during that particular quarter. Adding up all 11 sectors’ contributions yields the index’s overall return in the first quarter of 2015.
Comparing this GDP-weighted index to the S&P 500 over time highlights some interesting differences in performance. The graph below charts the relative performance of the two indices during our 2005 to 2023 time period.
Total Returns of US GDP-Weighted vs. SPX
Based on their total returns, the two indices tracked with statistical similarity from 2005 to mid-2009. But after 2009, the GDP-weighted index outperformed the S&P 500 by over half a percentage point each year up until 2023.
The summary statistics reflect these results as well. The US GDP-weighted index averaged an annualized return of 10.11% compared to 9.61% for the S&P 500 over the sample period. The US GDP-weighted index also had a lower average beta — 0.98 — over the sample period.
| GDP Index | SPX | |
| Mean Total Return | 10.11% | 9.61% |
| Max. Total Return | 35.23% | 32.39% |
| Min. Total Return | –35.33% | –36.99% |
| Std. Dev. Total Teturn | 18.45 | 18.00 |
| Mean Skewness | –0.27 | –0.22 |
All in all, the results indicate that a US GDP-weighted index may offer the potential for excess returns with similar levels of risk compared to its benchmark.
To be sure, our results occur over a limited time period of 18 years. So while it is too early to make a definitive statement about what such an index can deliver relative to a value-weighted index like the S&P 500, this is definitely an area worthy of further study and analysis.
If you liked this post, don’t forget to subscribe to the Enterprising Investor.
All posts are the opinion of the author. As such, they should not be construed as investment advice, nor do the opinions expressed necessarily reflect the views of CFA Institute or the author’s employer.
Image credit: ©Getty Images / Peach_iStock
Professional Learning for CFA Institute Members
CFA Institute members are empowered to self-determine and self-report professional learning (PL) credits earned, including content on Enterprising Investor. Members can record credits easily using their online PL tracker.
Derek Horstmeyer
Patrick McManus
